When renewal comes, I want to show in numbers what the customer received, so the negotiation does not reduce to a discount conversation.
Khi tới kỳ gia hạn, tôi muốn chỉ ra bằng con số rằng khách đã nhận được gì, để cuộc thương lượng không quy về mỗi chuyện giảm giá.
Job context
- Who
- An account owner defending the current price
- When
- Sixty days before the term ends
- Trigger
- The customer's procurement asks for a reduction to renew
- Situation
- The cost sits plainly on an invoice while the value is scattered through daily work
- Constraints
- No access to the customer's internal systems to pull figures
5 Pains
There is no before-baseline
HighNobody measured the old state, so the new one compares with nothing.
Root cause: At signing everyone wants to start; nobody wants to measure
The value lives in things that did not happen
HighIncidents avoided and hours saved are both absences.
Root cause: No system records what did not happen
The beneficiary and the signer are different people
HighThe using team sees the value; procurement sees a cost line.
Root cause: Benefit is diffuse across the organisation while cost is concentrated in one line
Numbers from the vendor are not believed
MediumA vendor scoring itself has every number read as marketing.
Root cause: The measurer and the beneficiary of the measurement are the same
The original champion has left
MediumThe memory of why this was bought leaves with the person, and people move on.
Root cause: The reason for buying is recorded nowhere but in memory
5 Desired Outcomes
Have a baseline to compare against
FunctionalPut a number on what did not happen
FunctionalSpeak the signer's language
SocialNumbers the customer believes
FunctionalEnter the renewal without feeling like a supplicant
Emotional
5 Existing Solutions
A solution is not the same thing as a product — a customer can hire a behaviour or a workaround too.
A vendor-authored value report
ProductThorough and read as marketing, because the vendor is scoring itself.
Collect testimony from users
BehaviourMore persuasive to the signer than data, and it does not scale.
Take a baseline at signing
BehaviourThe only approach that truly solves it, and it must be done twelve months before it is needed.
Write the buying reason into a shared document
WorkaroundAccount owners build the customer organisation's memory because it does not keep its own.
Discount to keep the contract
BehaviourThe always-available exit, which converts a value question into a price question.
2 Opportunity Gaps
Proving value requires a baseline, and the baseline must be taken when nobody yet cares about proving anything.
Why existing solutions fail: At signing every incentive points toward starting fast; a baseline slows things down and returns nothing visible for a year.
Potential opportunity: Making the baseline the first step of onboarding itself rather than an extra task.
The benefit is spread across the organisation while the cost is concentrated in one department's line.
Why existing solutions fail: The signer is judged on their own department's cost while the benefit lands in another, so cutting this is a correct decision for them.
Potential opportunity: Translating value into the unit the signer is judged on rather than the unit the user feels.