When I am about to borrow a large sum for a home, I want to know whether I can carry it for years, so I do not put my family into a risk I have not fully counted.
Khi tôi định vay một khoản lớn để mua nhà, tôi muốn biết mình có gánh nổi trong nhiều năm không, để không đặt cả gia đình vào một rủi ro mình chưa tính hết.
Job context
- Who
- Someone about to take the largest loan of their life
- When
- Before signing the loan
- Trigger
- The bank approving more than expected
- Situation
- The approved amount is not the sensible amount
- Constraints
- Rates move and income is not guaranteed
5 Pains
No idea what level of borrowing is safe for them
HighWhat the bank approves is not the answer.
Root cause: Limits are computed on current capacity, not on future risk
A floating rate can rise
HighWith nobody saying how far.
Root cause: The introductory rate applies only for the first period
The terms are not fully understood
HighA long contract written for insiders.
Root cause: Contracts are written for legal tightness rather than for the borrower to understand
The adviser is also selling the loan
HighSo the advice leans toward borrowing more.
Root cause: Loan officers are measured on the amount lent
The loss-of-income case is not considered
MediumBecause nobody wants to think about it at a happy moment.
Root cause: No step in the process forces the downside to be examined
5 Desired Outcomes
Know a safe level of borrowing for their situation
FunctionalKnow the payment if rates rise
FunctionalUnderstand the terms being signed
FunctionalGet advice from someone not selling the loan
SocialBe confident the downside was counted
Emotional
5 Existing Solutions
A solution is not the same thing as a product, a customer can hire a behaviour or a workaround too.
Compare rates across banks
BehaviourWhat everyone does, comparing the easiest number rather than the risk.
Use a repayment calculator
ProductGives today's number and does not model income disappearing.
Ask someone who has borrowed
BehaviourThe frankest source, from conditions that have since changed.
Hire an independent financial adviser
ServiceSolves the actual problem, and few pay for advice when advice is free elsewhere.
Borrow less than approved
BehaviourThe most effective self-protection, suggested by nobody in the process.
2 Opportunity Gaps
The only person sitting with the borrower to explain is measured on the amount lent, so all the available advice leans toward borrowing more.
Why existing solutions fail: Independent advice must charge directly while the bank's is free because it is priced into the interest, so borrowers choose what looks free and pay far more by another route.
Potential opportunity: A fixed-fee independent review, positioned as an ordinary step before signing.
Banks measure current capacity to repay because that is what documents can prove, while what decides a twenty-year loan is resilience when circumstances change, which nobody measures.
Why existing solutions fail: Borrowers read the approved limit as confirmation they can afford it, while it is only the level of risk the bank will accept, two very different things nobody distinguishes at any step.
Potential opportunity: Showing repayments under adverse scenarios, a rate rise, one income lost, beside the approved limit.